Press "Enter" to skip to content

Are You Overpaying for Your 401(k)? A Guide to Fiduciary Duty and Plan Benchmarking

0

Recent years have brought a dramatic rise in excessive 401(k) fee litigation, putting increased pressure on employers to ensure they are meeting their fiduciary obligations.  The U.S. Department of Labor’s Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) enforces strict standards of conduct for those who manage employee benefit plans; maintaining a compliant plan requires proactive oversight.  The retirement plan you initially started with may not always be a good fit now; a lot has changed in recent years.  To protect both your employees’ financial futures and your business’s bottom line, regular plan reviews and fee assessments are not only essential, but will keep you out of trouble.

Understanding Fiduciary Responsibilities Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA)

Under ERISA guidelines, plan sponsors are legally required to act in the best interest of participants.  A primary component of this duty requires plan sponsors to ensure that only reasonable compensation is paid for services.  Failing to monitor these costs can lead to regulatory scrutiny, poor retirement outcomes for staff and even costly lawsuits.  Fortunately, one of the most reliable tools to demonstrate that a prudent, fiduciary process is being followed is plan benchmarking.

What is 401(k) Benchmarking?

Benchmarking is the process of evaluating if your retirement plan’s services and fees are competitive with other plans of a similar size and type.  Plan service providers must supply plan sponsors with the information they need to make better decisions about their retirement plan, including a 408(b)(2) disclosure which lists all fees, services and costs. 

Taking the time to benchmark your plan is highly valuable because it:
Helps plan sponsors determine the value of services provided
Helps demonstrate that a prudent, fiduciary process is being followed
Assesses the reasonableness of fees

Uncovering Hidden and “Sneaky” Costs

Many employers do not realize how much they or their employees are paying because fees are often split across different categories.  Even small, overlooked fees, buried in disclosure documents, can quietly erode your employees’ retirement savings and impact your business’s bottom line.  To gain a clear picture of your total plan expenses, you must analyze the “Big Three” fee categories:

Asset-Based Fees: These are percentages charged based on total assets under management, which cover investment management, fund expense ratios and advisory fees.  For a small plan with 25 participants and $250,000 in assets, the average total investment expense is approximately 1.26%.
Administrative Fees: These fees cover day-to-day operational costs like recordkeeping, compliance and customer support.  For small-to-midsize plans, these typical administrative costs average $60 to $90 per participant, annually.
Transaction Fees: These are one-off charges for things like loans, distributions or plan amendments.  Individual participant transactions can cost $75 to $175, while average employer transaction fees can run around $975 per year.

How to Benchmark Your Plan in 3 Simple Steps

To ensure your plan remains competitive and compliant, follow these steps to begin the benchmarking process:

Gather Your Key Documents: Start by locating your plan sponsor fee disclosure (408(b)(2)) and participant fee disclosure (404(a)(5)).  By law, providers are required to provide these disclosures to you.  You may also need your adoption agreement and plan trust statement.
Break Down the Fees: Carefully review your 408(b)(2) disclosure and other documents to understand your plan details and the fees associated with managing your plan.  Analyzing plan fees can help you gain a baseline understanding of your current plan.
Compare Against the Market: Weigh your total “all-in” costs and service levels against modern providers to see if you are getting fair value or if it is time to renegotiate or switch.  A high-performing, low-fee 401(k) ensures your employees’ contributions actually go toward their future, making your benefits package much more competitive.

How Often Should You Benchmark?

Regular reviews are not just good practice—they are a core fiduciary expectation to ensure your fees align with the current market. 
The Department of Labor recommends benchmarking at least once every three years.
Further industry standards recommend reviewing and benchmarking your plan at least once every three to five years, though some employers do it annually.
Understanding and evaluating plan fees, investment expenses, investment options and services is an essential fiduciary responsibility.

As your headcount and plan balance grow, outdated fee structures can quietly cost you and your team thousands of dollars.  If you want to ensure your plan is working hard for your business without overcharging, consider requesting a complimentary benchmarking report to have a specialist review your disclosures and show you exactly where your plan stands.  

If all of this sounds confusing, but you don’t want to risk not being in compliance, reach out to us and we can help with a review of your current plan.

While I make every attempt to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the information provided in this article, the information is provided “as-is” without warranty of any kind. PayMaster, Inc and Romeo Chicco do not accept any responsibility or liability for the accuracy, content, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information contained. Tax laws can and will change. Consult with your CPA, Tax Attorney or HR Professional to ensure compliance.

Leave a Reply